For Rent on Fishers Island

Please inquire about our off-season availability and pricing.

Advanced Rental Search

Please call us for personalized assistance with your rental booking and for additional listings that may not be featured.
(631) 788-7921
e-mail info@shuttersandsails.com

ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL SUMMER RENTAL

Owls Nest

West End
  • Beds: 5
  • Baths: 3
  • Sleeps: 10
  • BOOK TODAY!: Spring Special

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Harbor View Cottage

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 1.5
  • Sleeps: 6

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Milliken House

East End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 4.5
  • Sleeps: 10

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

The Pumphouse

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 2
  • Baths: 1.5
  • Sleeps: 5
  • BOOK TODAY!: Spring Special

Check Availability

ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL SUMMER RENTAL

Finan by the Sea

West End
  • Beds: 5
  • Baths: 4
  • Sleeps: 10
  • BOOK TODAY!: Spring Special

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Holiday Hill

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 5
  • Baths: 3
  • Sleeps: 10

Check Availability

ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL SUMMER RENTAL

Oceanhill

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2
  • Sleeps: 6
  • BOOK TODAY!: Spring Special

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Oyster Barn

East End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 5
  • Baths: 3.5
  • Sleeps: 10

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Pirates Cove Cottage

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 2
  • Baths: 2
  • Sleeps: 4

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Highball

East End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2
  • Sleeps: 8

Check Availability

Featured
ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL SUMMER RENTAL

Hydrangea House

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 2
  • Sleeps: 8

Check Availability

Featured
ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Leeway

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 3
  • Sleeps: 7

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Love Shack

East End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 3
  • Sleeps: 6

Check Availability

ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL SUMMER RENTAL

Hanes Flinn House

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 5
  • Baths: 4
  • Sleeps: 10

Check Availability

ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL SUMMER RENTAL

FI Getaway

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 2.5
  • Sleeps: 8
  • BOOK TODAY!: Spring Special

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Braun House

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 3
  • Sleeps: 6

Check Availability

ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Yellow House

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 2.5
  • Sleeps: 8

Check Availability

Featured
ACTIVE SUMMER RENTAL

Just Right

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 4
  • Baths: 1.75
  • Sleeps: 8

Check Availability

ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL SUMMER RENTAL

The Laughing Place

West End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 7
  • Baths: 2
  • Sleeps: 10
  • BOOK TODAY!: Spring Special

Check Availability

ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL

Osprey Hill

East End, Fishers Island
  • Beds: 5
  • Baths: 4.5
  • Sleeps: 10

Check Availability

ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL

Treetops

West End
  • Beds: 3
  • Baths: 2
  • Sleeps: 5

Check Availability

ACTIVE OFF SEASON RENTAL

Lake House

East End
  • Beds: 8
  • Baths: 7
  • Sleeps: 16
  • BOOK TODAY!: Spring Special

Check Availability

Featured
ACTIVE

Rabbit Run Cottage

East End
  • Bed: 1
  • Bath: 1
  • Sleeps: 2

Check Availability