FOR RENT
Welcome to Fishers Island, New England’s Best Kept Secret.
We are as excited to introduce new people to Fishers Island as we are to welcome back old friends. We find great joy to hear how within hours of arriving, the stresses of mainland life drain away.
Most rental houses include an additional utility and cleaning charge. Come experience all that island life has to offer!
Please call us for personalized assistance with your rental booking and for additional listings that may not be featured.
(860)331-1510
e-mail info@shuttersandsails.com
(Search by rental NAME, DATE, ROOM #, etc.)
| Rental Name |
Sleeps | BR | Area | Description | Weekly Rental |
Avail Cal |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 |
Hill Cottage | 9 | 5 | West End | tucked into North Hill | $3,000/week | |
 |
White House | 6 | 3 | West End | screened porch and fenced yard in village | $3,000/week | |
 |
Braemar | 10 | 5 | West End | water view | $3,500/week | |
 |
Treetops | 5 | 3 | West End | comfortable cottage near village |
$3,500/week | |
 |
Love Shack | 6 | 3 | East End | Water View | $3,800/week | |
 |
KinderHaus | 8 | 3 | East End | contemporary near the Big Club, water views |
$3,850/week | |
 |
Rabbit Run Cottage | 4 | 1 | East End | secluded cottage,water views, utilities included | $3000/week, Utilities Included, 2 Week Minimum | |
 |
The Laughing Place | 10 | 7 | West End | large house in the Village |
$5,000/week | |
 |
Leeway | 7 | 4 | West End | Waterfront, Private Beach | $6,000/week | |
 |
Montauk Big House | 22 | 10 | West End | large cottage, sunset & water views |
$6,000/week, 2 Week Minimum | |
 |
Yellow House | 8 | 4 | West End | updated Officer's Row house, water view |
$6,000/week, 2 Week Minimum | |
 |
Braun House | 6 | 3 | West End | waterfront, stunning harbor views |
$6,000/week, 2 Week Minimum | |
 |
Robert’s Folly | 8 | 4 | West End | large back yard fenced koi pond |
$6,000/week, 3 week minimum | |
 |
Houghton House | 11 | 5 | East End | breathtaking views, private beach |
$6,000/week, 3 Week Minimum | |
 |
Cameron House | 13 | 6 | West End | Beautiful 6 bedroom West End cottage. | $6,500/week, Full Month Preferred | |
 |
Milliken House | 10 | 4 | East End | waterviews, private | $6,750/week, 2 Week Minimum | |
 |
Harbourscape | 13 | 5 | West End | large house, stunning views |
$8,500/week | |
 |
Osprey Hill | 10 | 5 | East End | secluded house, water view |
$9,500/week, 3 Week Minimum | |
 |
Brooks Point House | 12 | 6 | East End | secluded house near club water views |
2020 Availability! | |
 |
The Cabin | 6 | 3 | East End | Large front porchnear Isabella Beach | Booked Summer 2020! | |
 |
Lake House | 16 | 8 | East End | spacious, private, lakefront |
Booked Summer 2020! | |
 |
Fort House | 10 | 4 | West End | Officer's Row house with water view |
Booked Summer 2020! | |
 |
West Harbor House | 12 | 5 | West End | large house, sunset and water views |
Booked Summer 2020! | |
 |
Hanes Flinn House | 10 | 5 | West End | Large, updated house | Call for Pricing |