FOR SALE

Call us for listings that may not be featured on the website.

Ave B Cottage
PRICE REDUCED!
Charming West End Cottage on Avenue B

3 Bedrooms  1 Baths  .140 Acres

$395,000

This charming 884 square foot Fishers Island cottage is set among mature trees, flowering shrubs, and stone walls.

Read More

Hydrangea Hall
NEW!
Halcyon House

5 Bedrooms  2 Baths  0.14 Acres

$575,000

Read More

Braemar

5 Bedrooms  2 Baths  .27 Acres

$770,000

Let the wonders of island life engulf you from this charming home on the west end of Fishers Island.

Read More

Brooks Point House
Brooks Point

6 Bedrooms  4 Baths  2.38 Acres 3925 Sqft 12 Rooms

$1,625,000

Charming home with water views nestled on the private and scenic East End of Fishers Island, just a short distance away from both the Big Club and driving range.

Read More

Winthrop Drive

4 Bedrooms  2.5 Baths  .50 Acres

$775,000

Rocking chair porch welcomes you to this warm and relaxing West End home on private .50 acre plot.

Read More

Rugg Estate
Harbourscape

5 Bedrooms  5.5 Baths  2 Acres

$2,575,000

Perched on a hill, this home has a commanding view of West Harbor, Pirates Cove and Fishers Island Sound, and… stunning sunrises.

Read More

Four Winds
PRICE REDUCED!
Four Winds

6 Bedrooms  6 Baths  1.75 Acres

$1,600,000

Modern home set on hillside with views toward Hay Harbor and the Connecticut shoreline.

Read More

Madeline Ave Lot
Madeline Ave Lot

.30 Acres

$350,000

Build your dream home or weekend retreat on this beautiful lot surrounded by trees with views of West Harbor.

Read More

Hold the Fort
SOLD!
Hold the Fort

Loft Bedrooms  1 Baths  .340 Acres

$425,000

Right off the ferry, this adorable island cottage overlooks Silver Eel Cove.

Read More

Under Contract!
Whistler Avenue

3 Bedrooms  1 Baths  

$325,000

Settle into the beauty of Fishers Island in this historic 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom Condo-Townhouse.

Read More

Chocomount Cove Beach House
SOLD!
Chocomount Cove Beach House

3 Bedrooms  2 Baths  1.8 Acres

Sold January 2019

This waterfront beach house is set along Chocomount Cove for truly amazing sunsets and relaxed island living.

Read More

JUST SOLD!
Darby’s Cove Lot

4+ Acres

Sold January 2019

Abundant with natural beauty and wonderful view of West Harbor, this lot includes one of the highest elevations on Fishers Island.

Read More